Sunday, February 28, 2010

Flew's flown

The first Dictionary of Philosophy I ever owned, as an undergrad back in the '70s, was by Antony Flew. What a strange, sad story he's become. How shamefully he's being exploited, in his senescence. Talk about a bird flying out of the light, back into darkness.

Flew argued that “God” is too vague a concept to be meaningful. For if God’s greatness entails being invisible, intangible and inscrutable, then he can’t be disproved — but nor can he be proved. Such powerful but simply stated arguments made Flew popular on the campus speaking circuit; videos from debates in the 1970s show a lanky man, his black hair professorially unkempt, vivisecting religious belief with an English public-school accent perfect for the seduction of American ears. Before the current crop of atheist crusader-authors — Richard Dawkins, Daniel Dennett, Christopher Hitchens — there was Antony Flew. 


He's not all there now.


But there is a very good new dictionary of philosophy, by Simon Blackburn. And now there's a brand-new iPod app for that. It's in my hip-pocket.


(And of course, the classic in the genre: Voltaire's.)

1 comment:

Kristin Mary Johnson said...

Flew's comments on God remind me of that Hitchhiker's Guide thing in your Mr. Deity blog and the "bidirectional playability" of the proof factor.

KurzweilAI.net Accelerating Intelligence News